Tuesday, July 19, 2022
Tuesday, July 12, 2022
Gwynedd Council Fail.: One Councillor Walked Out Of The Meeting.
Cyngor Gwynedd council held a hybrid Planning Committee on Monday, 4th July, 2022. The webcast can be found here -
https://gwynedd.public-i.tv/core/portal/webcast_interactive/681487
The meeting has already attracted media attention -
'Gwynedd planners went against officers' recommendations to allow the
development on Ffordd Capel Coch after hearing it was the "only way" a
local woman could afford to continue living in the village'
That article can be found here -
https://www.msn.com/en-gb/news/uknews/llanberis-bungalow-build-granted-amid-pleas-to-help-keep-welsh-speaking-family-in-area/ar-AAZjAjK
The committee dealt with other applications.Those watching the live webcast in english were not able to hear the english speaking participants due to a sound failure. The failure does not occur in the Welsh version. One participant mentioned vested interests and a possible judicial review - but you have to listen to the Welsh version to hear her.
Just under four minutes of the wecast in english are missing. It is not down to the sound failure(s)...
In
a previous meeting, the long suffering Planning officer mentioned
possible Government intervention due to decisions overturned by council
members. Government can only investigate if a complaint is received.
Anyone can make a complaint....
On Thursday, 7th July, the Care Scrutiny Committee held a meeting -
The agenda and link to the recorded meeting can be found here -
https://democracy.gwynedd.llyw.cymru//ieListDocuments.aspx?CId=394&MId=4704
One
agenda item was to appoint members to attend performance challenge
monitoring meetings with senior heads of departments. Six were required -
two each for Housing/Planning, Children and the Adults departments.
Councillors were slow to put their names forward even with prompting
from the new Chair - who is also a former Chair.
Five Councillors eventually came forward - all from the Plaid group....
The
meeting was expected to pass the North Wales Market Stability Report
that links with the Population Needs Assessment - has that been
completed yet?. Officer's admitted the report was not perfect - yet a
vote was asked for...
Just as happened with the Care Scrutiny Committee meeting held on 3rd February, 2022...
More here -
https://gwyneddsfailingcouncil.blogspot.com/2022/02/cyngor-gwynedd-council-scrutiny.html
One Councillor said it took her three days to read cover to cover because it was all 'jumbled up'.
Another walked out of the meeting after complaining about the state of the paperwork presented...
In
last weeks other meetings, one Councillor stated there was no interest
from the public regarding the Employment Appeals meetings. Of course
there is public interest but these meetings usually take place with the
public and press removed. Why would the Councillor say this - at such a
time?
One Councillor appeared to nod off during another
meeting - this meeting was not webcast but held over Zoom where the
public have to ask for the link to join 'live'. What happens to these
Zoom meetings afterwards? The meetings are not available on the
council's website - are they simply deleted?
Cyngor Gwynedd Council Fail.: One Councillor Walked Out Of The Meeting - Cyngor ...:
Wednesday, July 06, 2022
Cyngor Gwynedd Council Fail.: Wales Audit Recognise Cyngor Gwynedd Council - For...
Cyngor Gwynedd council held a Cabinet meeting on Tuesday, 28th, June, 2022 -
https://gwynedd.public-i.tv/core/portal/webcast_interactive/679724
One Councillor spoke of his experiences on social media and that people think the council live in ivory towers, do bugger all and collect bonuses for everything. He spoke of the council's plans for the future outlined in the agenda and made a plea to the new CEO, Dafydd Gibbard, to ensure they were carried through...
He referenced paragraph 5 of Mr Gibbard's statement in an attempt to rebuff criticism on Facebook -
The full statement and meeting agenda can be found here -
https://democracy.gwynedd.llyw.cymru/documents/g4693/Public%20reports%20pack%2028th-Jun-2022%2013.00%20The%20Cabinet.pdf?T=10
Can we have a factcheck, please?
The
new CEO has only been in post for a year and may not have read all the
reports relating to past performance and failures of this council - but
'recognised as performing excellently...'
By whom? Which departments?
Certainly
not the Children and Families department which has been undertaking
'fake assessments' on disabled children - their complaints process
manipulated to shut down complaints - interference in 'independent'
investigations and behaviour by senior officer's which 'outraged' even
the Ombudsman.
On training staff, the former Cabinet Member for
Children, Dilwyn Morgan, warned in November, 2021 - "it would frighten
you how few members of staff undertake these trainings..."
Nor
the Adult SS, which Dilwyn Morgan now has responsibility for, with
recent Ombudsman investigations highlighting serious failings in this
department, too. Have all the recommendations arising from the
investigations been carried out yet? A reminder to the Member to seek
robust evidence of compliance not just an officer's word...
It
is a concern that neither the Children's nor Adult SS departments have
allowed proper scrutiny of their Annual Complaints Reports since 2019.
Three years with no proper scrutiny - a pandemic - and the Director with
ultimate responsibility for both departments now leaving the council.
Mr
Gibbard mentions 'recognition' from the Wales Audit Office - for what? A
Wales Audit Office report from January, 2022 into Gwynedd council can
be found here -
https://www.audit.wales/sites/default/files/publications/gwynedd_performance.pdf
From the report -
There is more....The report is not positive.
The CEO gives Care Inspectorate Wales a mention, too. The CIW's time would be better spent ensuring its past recommendations for improvement have been fully complied with. Gwynedd council have a history of not carrying through with agreements made...
And Estyn and local education...There is still the issue of Headteacher, Neil Foden, who claimed the council threw him under a bus during the school meals fiasco. The Education officer failed to answer a Committee and a public update regarding the video of the headteacher appearing to have a pupil by the neck is also outstanding.
Perhaps, Beca Brown, the new Cabinet Member for Education, could give an update?
In the past year, the council has now lost its two most senior Executive officer's.
Just over a year ago, an investigation report was completed and presented to the council - has it been released?
In
other news, the Information Commissioner is currently 'advising' the
council to release information first asked for in 2020 and on the
subject of data law - how long does an internal review of an FOI request
take nowadays?
Openess and transparency...
Cyngor Gwynedd Council Fail.: Wales Audit Recognise Cyngor Gwynedd Council - For...: