Sunday, August 21, 2016

The town where 100 young people have tried to kill themselves.

When Justin Trudeau came to power in Canada, he promised to repair the country’s relationship with its Aboriginal people, after centuries of discrimination. A disproportionate number of indigenous women have gone missing or been murdered in recent decades, and suicide attempts have risen dramatically in some communities, writes Stephen Sackur.
Attawapiskat is hard to reach. Generations of Canadian politicians have never lent it a thought, still less a visit. But this ramshackle Aboriginal settlement south of Hudson Bay has been making national news over the past year for the grimmest of reasons.
Last October a 13-year-old girl, Sheridan Hookimaw, headed to the rubbish dump and hanged herself. Since then more than 100 of Attawapiskat’s 2,000 First Nation people, most of them teenagers, but one just 11 years old, have attempted suicide.
Jackie Hookimaw, a Cree native of Attawapiskat, a teacher, and Sheridan’s aunt offers to show me around.
Attawapiskat
We set off down a dirt track past wooden cabins with boats and tepees in the backyard. A teenage boy is loading containers on to a quad bike outside a shed.
“That’s the water treatment plant,” says Jackie. “It’s the only place to get drinking water. The stuff that comes out of the tap is so toxic folks won’t shower in it, let alone drink it. We get everything here from rashes to cancers.”
The track takes us to a sports hall. There’s a makeshift gym, dumbbells, a couple of weight machines and a fug of stale sweat.
Skylar Hookimaw
I meet 19-year-old Skylar Hookimaw, his brow furrowed, biceps straining. Sheridan was his little sister. “It still doesn’t feel real, like it didn’t happen, but it did,” he sighs.
There’s a heavy silence. “Why is it happening so often?” I ask.
“Family problems, bullying, drugs, alcohol,” says Skylar. “Kids feel like they’ve been left alone, like they don’t matter.”
Map showing location of AttawapiskatWhite line 10 pixels

Back in April, 11 youngsters tried to kill themselves over the course of one weekend. The day before I arrived, a teenage girl slashed her wrists and had to be airlifted out. The week before, an “at risk” boy tried to hang himself.
Jackie takes me out on a canoe on the Attawapiskat River. Her people have fished here, hunted goose and caribou, for countless generations. We glide past four girls playing in the water, diving, splashing, shrieking with laughter.
“You wouldn’t know it, but those girls are struggling,” says Jackie as she waves a greeting. “Our young people are lost. They don’t feel valued. They feel disconnected from their culture and they need help.”
Canada's Prime Minister Justin Trudeau takes part in a smudging ceremony during the National Aboriginal Day Sunrise Ceremony in Gatineau, Quebec, Canada, June 21, 2016Image copyrightREUTERS
Image captionJustin Trudeau at a smudging ceremony during the National Aboriginal Day Sunrise Ceremony in Gatineau in June
Help, claims Justin Trudeau, Canada’s youthful premier, is on its way. He’s promised a fresh start in Canada’s relationship with its 1.4 million Aboriginal citizens. He pledged more money for their communities, a new focus on education and mental health in First Nation reserves like Attawapiskat.
He’s also launched an inquiry into another dark aspect of the indigenous experience in modern Canada – the shockingly disproportionate levels of violence directed against First Nation women. In the past 30 years more than 4,000 indigenous women have gone missing or been murdered.
Many of them fall through the cracks when they get to Canada’s cities. The police, the courts, social services all have a shameful record of failure – failure to protect, to investigate, to prosecute and ultimately to care.
Candle at vigil for Joey English
In prosperous Calgary, a western city grown rich on cattle and oil, I join a rain-soaked vigil to mark the death of 25-year-old Joey English. Her dismembered body was found in a city park in June.
A couple of dozen friends join Stephanie and Patsy, Joey’s mother and grandmother as they sing and drum and remember. “It’s like when you cut yourself and you can’t control the flow of the blood, that’s how I feel,” says Stephanie. When Joey’s grandmother speaks, the anger is raw. “I’m so pissed off with the justice system,” she says. “I’m so tired of this. Our families, our sisters need help.”
Beyond the small circle of mourners, Calgary’s streets are packed with revellers in the city for the annual Stampede – it’s all Stetsons and cowboy boots and a celebration of Canada’s Old West – the pioneers who settled a vast empty land. Except it wasn’t empty. It was the land of the Blackfoot, the Kainai, the Cree and so many more.
“We were taught to be silent,” says Sandra Manyfeathers, whose sister, Jacky Crazybull, was murdered during the Calgary Stampede nine years ago. “But we’re saying you’re not gonna kick us, you’re not gonna keep us down. No way are we gonna be quiet any more.”

Red River Women

Red River Women - Tina Fontaine
Each year, dozens of Canadian Aboriginal women are murdered or disappear never to be seen again. Some end up in a river that runs through the heart of Winnipeg. One of them was a 15-year-old school girl called Tina Fontaine, whose body was found in August 2014.
Read about Canada’s Red River Women.

Australia DPP Investigates Case of Boy Shafted by Prosecution and Own Lawyer.

We recently reported on the case of a 15-year Sudanese refugee, known only as ‘JB’, who spent seven years in prison for murder after both the prosecution and his own defence lawyer acted improperly by withholding evidence which raised significant doubt regarding his guilt.
Now, the NSW Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), Lloyd Babb SC (pictured), has launched an inquiry into the conduct of those involved.
The story so far…
A Supreme Court jury found that JB had fatally stabbed Mr Spowart, an innocent bystander, during a 2008 gang brawl in Sydney’s west, after he asked for a cigarette and was rebuffed.
“Apparently reacting out of a wounded sense of pride, the offender threw a punch,” the trial judge said.
“Despite his age, his life experience suggests that he was fully cognisant of the lethal nature of knife wounds inflicted to the chest and abdomen.”
The judge sentenced JB to 23 years in prison, with a 16-year non-parole period. The child served out nearly seven of those years, before new facts came to light that set him free in April this year.
Unreliable confession
A police informant, known as ‘A107’, claimed that JB had confessed to stabbing Edward Spoward around the time of a police interview, something which JB has always denied.
During the original trial, the prosecution submitted that the jury could confidently convict JB based on the alleged confession alone.
However, the fact that A107 was a police informant, and had avoided prison by testifying against JB, was never disclosed to JB’s barrister. In fact, it was withheld by the DPP solicitor, the prosecution barrister and the boy’s own criminal defence solicitor, Robert Kaufmann, who incredibly went on to represent A107 in the very case for which he avoided prison after testifying against JB – a monumental conflict of interest.
The failure to disclose this crucial information meant JB’s barrister was unable to cross-examine A107 about the fact he was a police informant and had a vested interest in testifying against JB.
The DPP will also be examining whether it was proper for the prosecution to submit that the jury could convict on the alleged confession alone, given that it knew the credibility of that supposed confession was significantly undermined by A107’s status and motive for testifying.
In the NSW Court of Criminal Appeal
The NSWCCA found in its April judgment that JB’s trial had miscarried because of “failures of the prosecuting authority”.
The Attorney-General himself supported JB’s appeal, submitting that the prosecution had failed in its ethical duties in a number of significant respects. Among other things, the Attorney-General acknowledged that the Crown Prosecutor and his instructing solicitor had met with A107, but notes of that meeting “appear to have been edited” and did not mention that A107 was a police informant.
When A107 told police JB had confessed to stabbing Spowart, A107 was himself facing charges of having defrauded victims of $40,000.
Police later swore an affidavit which outlined the vital “assistance” A107 had given police in the JB case, and A107 avoided prison altogether primarily because of that affidavit.
Where to now?
The conduct of all parties will now be assessed by the DPP, who has the power to bring criminal charges for a range of offences, including perverting the course of justice.
NSW Police have also launched their own internal investigation into the matter.
It is unclear whether complaints have been made to the Legal Services Commissioner against the prosecution and defence lawyers concerned.
One would expect those involved to face serious consequences, in order to deter others who may similarly discard their ethical obligations for their own purposes, regardless of the interests of justice.
http://www.sydneycriminallawyers.com.au/blog/dpp-investigates-case-of-boy-shafted-by-prosecution-and-own-lawyer/